The "Stroad" to Ruin - I Love it!

Picture provided by Not Just Bikes



As a few of you probably know, I've had a bit of an issue with the recent reconstruction of Comrie Avenue in Johnstown. Comrie Avenue is part of the 188 mile long Adirondack Trail Scenic Byway which stretches from Fonda to Malone.  T
he State's Corridor Management Plan requires such routes to be bicycle and pedestrian friendly, and that any roadwork to replace, expand or repair these roads incorporate bicycle and pedestrian design. The work that took place on Comrie Avenue did the opposite. It eliminated the existing shoulders that met or exceeded the 4’ requirement, and replaced them with nothing but little signs and a prayer that drivers are not having a bad day, or bad attitude. 

Comrie Avenue's redesign is the second time, I am aware of, that cycling facility engineering knowledge out of Region 2 - the NYSDOT region that controls that corridor and appears to be lead on these projects - has been suspect. In 2012, a waitress for Romano’s Pizzeria, Jeri L. Bursese, became severely injured (her legs were crushed by a Walmart Tractor Trailer) near the intersection of Route 30a and Route 67. Her bicycle front wheel fell through an incorrectly aligned road drainage grate which she was forced to travel over because of the narrow width of the road and the amount of traffic in the area. During deposition, the Resident Engineer stated, "...that he had not seen the construction plans for Route 30A prior to this case, had not read Chapter 17 of the Highway Design Manual relating to bicycle facility design, and was not familiar with the AASHTO guidelines for bicycle safe grates.” Presumably, he wasn't aware of the New York State touring route requirements either. Drawing a line between the lack of apparent knowledge of state guidelines, the fact that New York State lost the lawsuit Ms. Bursese brought against it, and the current redesign of the road which minimizes bicycle safety, makes me wonder if a lack of understanding of the requirements is again (or still) in play. 
 
Basically, Comrie Avenue is a type of road labeled a "STROAD" by the urban design group Strong Towns. Stroads, according to Strong Towns, are dangerous to cyclists, cars and pedestrians, expensive to build and maintain, and not particularly cost effective. It begs a question why anyone would spend millions of dollars to create one. It's as if NYSDOT's playbook for road construction stopped being updated in 1975.

The bottom line is that I'd like to be safe on a road designated as a cycling route by my state. Right now, I'm not. Please watch the YouTube site Not Just Bikes, commenting on Strong Towns issue with Stroads. You'll get a serious 18-minute education out of this one:


Comments

Popular Posts