Buffalo to Pittsburgh: Day 4 and The Kindness of Strangers

 



Buffalo to Pittsburgh Day 4

Part 1

Buffalo to Pittsburgh: Day 4 Emlenton to Pittsburgh (Almost)


Heading out of Gaslight Campground we knew to expect that a lot of the day was going to be road riding. In fact, as designed, only 5.1 miles of a planned 63.5 mile day would be on cycleway. The elevation profile warned us of hills, but the computer-generated profile was not especially horrific compared to the previous days with their sharp spikes:

Elevation view courtesy of Komoot

But the route concocted by Komoot, and the reality shown by Strava (the route actually taken), bear little resemblance to each other. Somewhere in Komoot's mapping software, there's a breakdown in communication with the planet it's actually on. 


Elevation view courtesy of Strava

Komoot is also supposed to design routes that take the mode of transportation into account (in this case, cycling). Yet it all too often chose roads that were just downright dangerous. Take this Google screenshot of Wildwood Sample Road. There are no margins at all. Just guardrail and hillside. The road was quite busy, and it was constantly snaking about so that there were few clear lines of sight. It's hard to express visually how dangerous this is to operate on with a bicycle.

Wildwood Sample Road, courtesy of Google Street View

Komoot is also supposed to take terrain into account (as much as possible - Western PA is hilly and that's just reality). Yet, on several occasions it took us on sharp-turned near-vertical zero-margin roads. In the picture below, Royalview Drive, we actually stopped on a person's lawn and told ourselves this was nuts and we needed to find a better way. Fortunately, the homeowner came out, provided us water, and was very helpful in helping us adapt our route. We sent him a thank you card.


Royalview Drive, courtesy of Google Street View

The picture above also illustrates the difficulty in merely using Google Street View to determine difficulties with elevation whilst sitting in one's bathrobe hundreds of miles away. You'd be forgiven for thinking, "This doesn't look that bad." What you can't see well is that this was at least an 8% grade and, like many similar roads already traversed, would have had to have been walked if we'd girded our loins and attempted it. Frankly, I think there were about a dozen such roads, but I admit that may be the lingering psychological pain speaking.

All told there were at least 5233 feet of climb on this day's ride. For reference, if you start at Wilmington, NY and drive to the observation platform at Whiteface Mountain Summit, you will have climbed 4867 feet. That is hard enough that there is a yearly Whiteface Mountain Uphill Bike Race. Now, imagine doing more than that over the course of a 63.5 mile cycling day. We're only average riders. There are no superheroes in the bunch - well, maybe Julie because she runs marathons and stuff. So, it was a lot and it really took a toll on us.

Roughly 20 miles into the ride Julie went on ahead. She had to make certain she was able to pick up their rental car before the dealer closed. About 40 miles into the ride Steve was picked up by Julie since they were carpooling back. Barb and I went on ourselves from that point. Nine miles short of our destination at Point State Park, and right on the cusp of dusk, I managed a flat tire. By the time it was fixed, it was pitch dark on a fast moving road with no lighting. We had bike lights, of course, but it was questionable whether or not they would be sufficient to prevent becoming a statistic. 

We called the ride at that point, unable to finish.

With profound gratitude, we accepted a ride from local neighbors who took pity on us and transported us to our hotel in Pittsburgh. We still missed our train for the night (there's another learning lesson) and ended up getting a car from the same rental dealership Julie had the day before.

__________

Part 2

Route Design

Komoot (and Google Maps) will only generate routes that it knows are real. As it turns out, there may be an altogether better route for us to have taken. Much of it, unfortunately, is not recognized by the computer, so it refuses to create the path. In many cases, the areas cannot be verified with Google Street View either because the Street View car has never traveled in these areas and/or Google Street View is car-centric and ignoring bikes (but I'm more than happy to participate in making Google Bike a reality!!!).

Because there are no complete trails, Komoot did not tell us about the extension of the Allegheny trail south out of Emlenton, PA. Google showed the trail, but I tried to concentrate on using Komoot to build this route and didn't notice it was there. I just wasn't seasoned enough to realize my efforts should have been the amalgamation of multiple research avenues.


Allegheny Trail heading out of Emlenton, PA

You see, just before Foxburg there is a gap caused by a trucking business. This is why Komoot would not choose this as a route:


Allegheny Trail gap north of Foxburg

Trucking company seems to have a passable road

The big question is whether or not the trucking company will allow cyclists to cross the property, or whether or not there's an off ramp from the trail somewhere along the adjacent Harvey Road. Nothing tells us, so we may need to go back and do some recon.

The Allegheny River Trail then picks up again heading south out of Foxburg and runs down to about Parker, PA where it becomes a road ride for quite a distance.

But does it really?

Many miles south we may have a link-up to the Armstrong Trail, but the map doesn't clearly show that link-up. Further, if one magnifies the view one can see that the trail that comprises the Armstrong Trail continues northwest for a great distance paralleling the shoreline (and coincidentally bypassing one of only two major hills on this entire route.

Beginning of the Armstrong Trail??

So, is there more trail than the map shows? It makes a HUUUUGGGEEE difference to the planning of this trip to know the answer to this question. It also makes a huge difference whether or not the southern end of this section of the Armstrong trail has an outlet to road T581. If it does not, it is just a runt piece of trail with nothing but local value. Naturally, Google and Komoot do not have answers. Neither do the state and locally supplied trail maps for the Armstrong Trail. One would think such interconnection details would be important. Anyone? Buehler?

Enter Ride with GPS

While performing my post-ride analysis, I decided to throw yet another app into the mix mostly because it seemed, from some reports, that it would allow us to stitch together a route based on experience, and not simply because Google or Komoot agree with it (it will, but that feature isn't free). The app, Ride with GPS, didn't really give me better answers to the road T581 question, but it did throw a large and welcome curve ball further south on the Armstrong Trail where it enters the outskirts of Schenley, PA. On both Google and Komoot, the Armstrong Trail officially ends at Upper Allegheny Drive/T404 to the east of Schenley, PA. As far as those two apps are concerned, that's it. No mas. We'll be on the road having a nice little mountain hike-a-bike taking all manner of back country roads until we can finally get to Schenley proper (lends new feels to the song, "She'll be coming round the mountain when she comes)."

But further west on the other side of Schenley, Google makes reference to something called the Tredway River Trail Extension and shows two bridges as part of it at Schenley (though it and Komoot refuse to actually allow creation of a route across it? Odd). Ride with GPS takes this a step further and shows the Tredway River Trail as being part of something called The Baker Trail, but doesn't do much more with it than that. Just a name. I still can't build a route with the information. 

When I looked up The Baker Trail, I found that it's kind of a big deal. The Baker Trail is actually a stitched together trail much like New York State's Empire Trail. It links the Tredway River Trail, and the Armstrong Trail via an extension. However, the Baker Trail, in total, is 134 miles long. All of that and not a single mention. Amazing.

Why, pray tell, is this information not listed on Google or Komoot?!!!!!

Baker Trail, courtesy of Ride with GPS

On the other side of this bridge is the fledgling Butler-Freeport Community Trail. First I've heard of that one too. A little bit more research seems to indicate that all of these trails - Baker, Tredwell, Armstrong - are in the process of development. We just happen to be trying to create a route a wee bit before they're ready.

At Freeport, riders have a choice to cross the bike lane equipped Donald R. Lobaugh Bridge, or continue south to Braeburn. Some of that journey would be on the final portion of the Tredway River Trail, but once that ends it would be a series of significantly sketchy roads that the system claims are bike friendly.

No margins and not really bike friendly

Eventually, in Oakmont, riders can cross a supposedly bike lane equipped Allegheny River Bridge. However, this crossing looks really sketchy. The "bikeway" is just a sidewalk with no satisfactory access on either end. Since both roads spit the rider out onto Freeport Road, it's probably safer to take the Lobaugh Bridge.

From there south and west to Pittsburgh, there are simply no decent choices until The Three Rivers Heritage Trail. Riders will be threading their way through so-called bicycle safe side roads, possibly illegally traversing a railroad service road and dodging cars at a highway on ramp. I believe this is all about to improve, and recon of the changes that have taken place but are not yet recorded may show advances have already been made. They just aren't obvious from here.

You might think from all that I'm frustrated, bitter and ready to throw in the towel. You'd be wrong. I'm already planning a return trip to section bike areas and see if there are present solutions to some of these trail issues. No date has been set yet, but it's going to happen. I love the challenge!


__________

Part 3

Thank You


I'd like to end this letter with a thank you to all those who helped us along the way. From Jill the water lady, to the guy with the hose, to the man who gave us directions and water, to the man that offered to come back and check to see if we fixed Barb's back tire (second flat) and finally to the couple who went out of their way to take two vagabonds into the very heart of Pittsburgh at nearly 11pm. All of you were examples of neighborliness and whether we needed it or not we were thankful you offered. Thank you for rebuilding our faith in humanity!


Now, it's time for RAGBRAI






Comments

Popular Posts